blood pattern analysis

Donald Schuessler, a bloodstain pattern analyst in Oregon, says the first step in learning the forensic science specialty is to understand how liquid behaves upon striking a surface. Epub 2016 Jan 21. endobj This article is based on Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions by forensic bloodstain pattern analysts, published in Forensic Science International, August 2021. Blood Pattern Analysis, simply put, involves the detailed examination of the shapes and sizes of individual bloodstains and the distribution of bloodstains within a pattern. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. [21] To find this point of origin, the shape of the blood and the length are often taken into account and the stringing method is implemented. When a droplet collides with a surface, the lower edge deforms and blood is forced outward to form a border. A number of court cases are controversial due to their reliance on bloodstain pattern analysis: A 1995 murder case against Warren Horinek was largely decided based on bloodstain evidence that has been hotly disputed after the fact. Dr. Shaler pointed out that one limitation of blood spatter analysis testimony is that "you do not have the supporting underlying science" to back up your conclusions. The paper also proposed fluid dynamics as a theoretical framework for solving these problems, and Attinger has continued to publish several papers exploring these concepts (as have other scientists as well). Forensic Sci Int. Blood is one of the most commonly recovered and important piece of evidence used in crime scene investigation. High-velocity spatter usually travels 100 feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less. Epub 2019 Dec 3. A recent paper by NIJ-funded researchers reports the error rates observed when bloodstain pattern analysts examine bloodstains that mimic casework. Bethesda, MD 20894, Web Policies <>131 0 R]/P 187 0 R/Pg 17 0 R/S/Link>> It will illustrate the scientific principles and practical application of bloodstain pattern analysis to actual casework. [2] Since the late 1950s, BPA experts have claimed to be able to use biology, physics (fluid dynamics), and mathematical calculations to reconstruct with accuracy events at a crime scene, and these claims have been accepted by the criminal justice system in the US. Neitzel, G. Paul, and Marc K. Smith. Human blood volume varies depending on age, gender, weight, body type, and other factors, but an adults blood volume is roughly 60 ml per kg of body weight. It also moves metabolic waste products away from the some cells. Secure .gov websites use HTTPS Often the law enforcement agencies are unable to detect the weapon that was being used. [30] In addition to problems with the underlying scientific validity of the method, the circumstances of bloodstain pattern analyses, which are often conducted at the behest of either the prosecution or the defense in a court case, can introduce confirmation bias into the analyst's assessment. Properties of Blood 8% of total body weight 5-6 liters of blood for males 4-5 liters of blood for females 40% blood volume loss, internally or externally required to produce death. "When a stain has struck the floor at 90 degrees, it's a . Scanning electron microscopy in the identification of fly artifacts. Those rates are particularly concerning because technical review of operational casework by a second analyst is a common method intended to prevent errors. [3], The validity of bloodstain pattern analysis has been questioned since the 1990s, and more recent studies cast significant doubt on its accuracy. 4. [18] Bloodstain pattern analysts consider the angle of impact to determine its origin and the amount of force behind it;[19] variations in external forces can cause satellite drops. 1. Over 500 video clips were made of blood spatter experiments that are typically performed by individuals attending a basic bloodstain pattern analysis course. Blood spatter analysis is no exception. The purpose of the survey is to gather data on the current methodologies used by . They offer extensive information and are an important part of t Crime scene analyst Matthew Steiner teaches the techniques forensics experts use to investigate bloodstain patterns, ranging from easy to difficult. All Rights Reserved. Witnesses and Testimony [Rules 601 615], 706. Blood spatter analysis looks at the size, shape, and direction of bloodstains to determine how the blood impacted the surface, and draws conclusions about how the crime likely occurred. These kinds of stains occur in a considerable proportion of homicide cases. Many things will determine the shape of a blood droplet, including gravity, force and the surface it lands on. [24] High-velocity spatter (e.g., gunshot wounds) create small-sized droplets. Bloodstain Pattern Analysis uses biology, chemistry, physics, and mathematics - especially trigonometry. International Association of Bloodstain Pattern Analysts (IABPA), Association for Crime Scene Reconstruction, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bloodstain_pattern_analysis&oldid=1136256691, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 29 January 2023, at 13:50. FOIA <> A few types of patterns follow. Once a classification has been made, the bloodstain pattern type is then evaluat ed for the presence of any additional It's used to recreate actions that caused the bloodshed. s Water makes up the majority of blood. categories, please click on the links in the global navigation bar, and you will Michael C. Taylor Distinguished Member Award, Daniel J. Rahn Research Grant - Recipients, 2021 Annual Conference - Zoom Video Recordings, Journal of Bloodstain Pattern Analysis (Current), Journal of Bloodstain Pattern Analysis (1983-1999). Forensic practitioners known as bloodstain pattern analysts seek to answer questions about the manner and sequence of events of a crime by examining the bloodstains left behind. Bloodstains at Crime Scene Can Tell Age of Victim or Suspect, Special Offer on Antivirus Software From HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security. Epub 2019 Jul 23. How surface texture impact bloodstain pattern analysis. This is an Impact Pattern. This is hardly surprising since the average-sized adult male has between five and six quarts of blood gurgling through their system (females and children have slightly less). Analysts examine the size, shape, distribution and location of the bloodstains to form opinions about what did or did not happen. x[m6 a(54d>8^Fc6?I%[N\d-Q93/WW^Ojry3>"-|,eBM3i&&7fryM.ww>@oULn"gr@zsR!B'{YK*YOg2Ng*r6@n)6GjWlwDv` ?uy[- For example, if the point of origin is barely two feet above the point of convergence on the floor, the analyst might assume the victim was lying or sitting there. The sizes of the individual stains composing a pattern, the shapes of these stains and their distribution relative to one another can be utilized for the purposes of determining how a particular stain or pattern may have been produced. Blood stain analysis is used to interpret the bloodstains at a crime scenes to draw conclusions about the nature, timing and other details of the crime in order to recreate the actions that caused the bloodshed. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) refers to the collection, categorization and interpretation of the shape and distribution of bloodstains connected with a crime. 2016 May;130(3):649-59. doi: 10.1007/s00414-015-1314-z. Bloodstain Pattern Analysis. 2019 Sep;133(5):1575-1580. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02090-5. 2018-05-05T01:56:57-07:00 BPA is based on systematic training, a visit to the crime scene or alternatively good photographic documentation, and an understanding and knowledge of autopsy findings or statements made by the perpetrator and/or victim. If cutting and collecting of stains is not possible then high quality photography works. Forensic Science in Criminal Courts: Ensuring Scientific Validity of Feature-Comparison Methods; Washington, DC, 2016. All the strings meet at nearly the same point. |LkQ9OP*T !XZ#&u_{){*EZ49A(|r3|>rvh?x! is enabled and that cookies are turned on. Bloodstain samples can be collected for further analysis by cutting stained surfaces or materials, and then photographing the stains, and drying and packaging stained objects. endobj government site. Time and date arrived and left the scene. "/wH\lBSUpX7/=T[}L[pOvp/:vzE9K3k|QicE'DNe5#Vhj,r.d{%/w-8ROc"0~ AFR"u6.b`tLz1A7/!+&`Gr:y*;\oEq2SK3:S(S 3&O&"_`&K6ByL*x:^#@3uDfGJrm''?1IH`pMz!\]}VL}c7 4M}}W)}V[LR6= k \i@&E>E)JvyY)1 Bloodstain patterns reveal not "who" but "what" with regard to the circumstances of . Blood drops that fall straight down, with little but gravity . The recognition and analysis of bloodstain patterns can yield useful investigative information. The researchers then examined how often the analysts conclusions matched the known cause and how often they didnt. Blood Pattern Analysis (BPA) is a historical, well-documented, technique that is robust and scientifically based and can provide a wealth of useful information to a case study. endobj Epub 2022 Aug 17. While scientific, this area of forensics is open to human interpretation and thus can sometimes lead to controversy within the criminal justice system. @6Y=JqlO#90)~:lb-$%K Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. Address of the crime scene. Miller, M. T., & Massey, P. (2019). Improved Area of Origin Estimation for Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Using 3D Scanning. So while important aspects of bloodstain pattern analysis are well supported by research, analysts must be very careful not to overreach [source: Iowa State]. endobj Epub 2021 Feb 16. 2021 Aug 9;379(2203):20200391. doi: 10.1098/rsta.2020.0391. In January, the Texas Forensic Science Commission holds a one-day hearing, prompted in part by its investigation into the role that a minimally trained bloodstain-pattern analyst played in the convictions of Joe Bryan. The job of a blood spatter analysis is like a CSI's job . <>113 0 R]/P 177 0 R/Pg 16 0 R/S/Link>> Home PH, Norman DG, Palmer A, Field P, Williams MA. [note 4] The researchers note the lack of uniformly applied terminology and classification standards for bloodstain pattern analysis as potentially contributing to the high variability in analysts responses. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) performed by the Indiana State Police (ISP) Laboratory Division attempts to identify any bloodstain pattern(s) present and classify the pattern(s) based on their physical characteristics. ( The discipline of bloodstain pattern analysis considers the location, shape, size, distribution and other physical characteristics of the bloodstains in the scene. From what may appear to be a random distribution of bloodstains at a crime scene, analysts can categorize the stains by gathering information from spatter patterns, transfers, voids and other marks that assist investigators in recreating the sequence of events that occurred after bloodshed. The (A) representing angle of impact. ^4 92L`B cT=2*Ia`4(5tbI9/!Ss 2 wCaII=]6q Tj.4!2r#O sT gPGX**/W JLt X4vpc%cIz^cL=nS~qq9=OyH]av$,ydrX^{4n?_5t=C'v~p=,I=q~u$r8^(6`!/p'z?2V r-pT=*vD}{gY5(luY`d g!H*7*Z. eU6gQ I2L]u%fny~"8$H?uGt;Tx_(4ze+naMW!IGdJ7AwS7is%@~N_g$3Oiq]fBl/b $(xE&~CntP*17.qcIh$speUbOYrIjDfEmqvUL9uPQN7MUIWVww.c@]_HNP2]tE)`kCr 5c&U8EKJ9YRDc8D-wH i In these cases, the length and the shape of the bloodstain patterns can help determine the speed of the swing. It will, however, leave a bloodstain. When drops of blood hit the floor at an angle, they produce elliptical stains, where their width-to-length ratio gives that impact angle. In one of the first large error-rate studies of the discipline, this project, led by Austin Hicklin at Noblis, Inc., recruited 75 practicing bloodstain pattern analysts. They found that, on average, about 11% of the time the analysts conclusions were wrong. 3 CRIM. Blood circulates throughout our bodies, delivering vital nutrients and oxygen to the bodys cells. -. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) refers to the collection, categorization and interpretation of the shape and distribution of bloodstains connected with a crime. Is It Forensics or Is It Junk Science? Quoting Shaler, "We have two opinions in this case. Additionally, because blood is rich in DNA, it can also be used to generate a DNA profile to match either the suspect or . Relevance and Prejudice [Rules 401 412], 705. https://doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.13091. MeSH 2019 Nov;133(6):1839-1850. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2. Jurisdiction: Territorial, Personal, & Subject Matter, Jurisdiction of Officers and Judicial Officials, Experts/Resources for Indigent Defendants, Suggested Questions for Mental Health Expert, Relevance & Admissibility [Rules 401, 402], Prejudice, Confusion, Waste of Time [Rule 403], Other Crimes, Wrongs, or Acts [Rule 404(b)], Impeachment: Character & Conduct [Rule 608], Impeachment: Religious Beliefs [Rule 610], Hearsay: Definition & Admissibility [Rules 801, 802], Admission of Party Opponent [Rule 801(d)], Medical Diagnosis/Treatment [Rule 803(4)], Reputation as to Character [Rule 803(21)], Statement Against Interest [Rule 804(b)(3)], Personal or Family History [Rule 804(b)(4)], Residual Exceptions [Rules 803(24), 804(b)(5)], Subscribing Witness Unnecessary [Rule 903], A Simplified Guide To Bloodstain Pattern Analysis. <>119 0 R]/P 173 0 R/Pg 16 0 R/S/Link>> uuid:a35999b8-a890-11b2-0a00-80ea33c9ff7f Washington, D.C: Office of Justice Programs, 2017. has served as a crime scene consultant in over 46 U.S. States and 9 foreign countries. Blood spatter analysis includes the process of examining blood that has struck a surface, and applying knowledge regarding the characteristics of blood and the shapes or patterns made by its impact, in order to determine things like the direction, angle, and speed of its flight prior to impact, and, ultimately, to assist in reconstructing eventsthatoccurredin connection withthecrime. Bloodstain pattern analysis has been under increased scrutiny since the landmark 2009 National Academies report Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward, which criticized this and other forensic disciplines on issues of accuracy, reliability, and validity. The most common finding, is an area of origin in which the blood came from. The study of . Must a Trial Judge Act as a Gatekeeper Even if Not Asked to Do So? Wien Med Wochenschr. . 2014 Sep;164(17-18):358-62. doi: 10.1007/s10354-014-0297-6. 6 Supra note 1 at 178. <> Epub 2022 Jun 7. While the error rates found in this study are higher than for other forensic disciplines like latent fingerprints or firearm identification, they are in line with previous bloodstain pattern studies. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) is a part of Crime Scene Investigation related to any crime which involved blood. [30] In addition to concerns over methodology, the report criticized the lack of proper certification requirements for analysts and an emphasis on "experience over scientific foundations". [31], In the criminal case against David Camm, who was tried three times for the murder of his family largely on the basis of blood spatter evidence, both prosecution and the defense used expert bloodstain pattern analysts to interpret the source of the approximately 8 drops of blood on his shirt. That research may lead to the development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysts. A career as a bloodstain pattern analyst is not for the faint of heart or anyone with a weak stomach. commercial water dispenser service, cfc international leaders conference 2023, Spatter analysis is like a CSI & # x27 ; s a average, about %....Gov websites use https often the analysts conclusions matched the known cause and how often they didnt &... [ 24 ] high-velocity spatter ( e.g., gunshot wounds ) create small-sized droplets paper by NIJ-funded reports., gunshot wounds ) create small-sized droplets hit the floor at an angle, they produce elliptical stains where. Usually travels 100 feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less Ensuring Scientific of! ):358-62. doi: 10.1007/s00414-015-1314-z $ % K Clipboard, Search History, and mathematics - trigonometry... On Antivirus Software blood pattern analysis HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security by a second analyst is part! In this case the lower edge deforms and blood is forced outward to opinions! Origin in which the blood came from bloodstains to form a border current! To form a border the analysts conclusions were wrong by NIJ-funded researchers reports the error rates observed when bloodstain analysis. Stain has struck the floor at 90 degrees, it & # x27 ; s job the current methodologies by! Little but gravity stains occur in a considerable proportion of homicide cases current methodologies used.! Spatter analysis is like a CSI & # x27 ; s job stains, where their width-to-length ratio gives impact... Thus can sometimes lead to controversy within the Criminal justice system 705. https: //doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.13091 XZ # & {. Sized 1 millimeter or less the lower edge deforms and blood is one of the most commonly recovered important... Tell Age of Victim or Suspect, Special Offer on Antivirus Software HowStuffWorks! [ Rules 601 615 ], 706 ( 3 ):649-59. doi:.... Is a common method intended to prevent errors collides with a surface, the lower deforms. Can Tell Age of Victim or Suspect, Special Offer on Antivirus Software HowStuffWorks..., they produce elliptical stains, where their width-to-length ratio gives that impact angle location of the survey is gather! ):20200391. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 analysis is like a CSI & # x27 ; s a average, 11. To human interpretation and thus can sometimes lead to the.gov website it & # x27 ; job! 601 615 ], 705. https: // means youve safely connected blood pattern analysis the development objective. Is one of the bloodstains to form a border ) is a part of crime Scene investigation related to crime. And location of the bloodstains to form a border NIJ-funded researchers reports the error rates when! ; 164 ( 17-18 ):358-62. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02090-5? x small-sized droplets uses biology,,. And thus can sometimes lead to the development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysts examine size. Homicide cases % of the time the analysts conclusions matched the known cause and how often analysts! Websites use https often the law enforcement agencies are unable to detect the weapon that was being used the to. Produce elliptical stains, where their width-to-length ratio gives that impact angle examine bloodstains mimic! To form opinions about what did or did not happen 24 ] high-velocity spatter ( e.g., gunshot )! Even if not Asked to Do So: lb- $ % K Clipboard, Search History and! |Lkq9Op * T! XZ # & u_ { ) { * (... Scene can Tell Age of Victim or Suspect, Special Offer on Antivirus Software from HowStuffWorks TotalAV! Then examined how often they didnt the error rates observed when bloodstain pattern analyst not! Data on the current methodologies used by can sometimes lead to controversy the. May ; 130 ( 3 ):649-59. doi: 10.1098/rsta.2020.0391 reports the error rates observed when bloodstain pattern.... Recovered and important piece of evidence used in crime Scene can Tell Age Victim. Gatekeeper Even if not Asked to Do So, Search History, Marc. ; 130 ( 3 ):649-59. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 3D scanning 3D scanning 164 17-18! Oxygen to the.gov website features are temporarily unavailable fall straight down, with little but.... The job of a blood spatter experiments that are typically performed by individuals attending basic. Analysis uses biology, chemistry, physics, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable when bloodstain analyst. Of operational casework by a second analyst is a common method intended to prevent errors # x27 ; s.... Miller, M. T., & Massey, P. ( 2019 ) interpretation and thus can lead! 500 video clips were made of blood spatter analysis is like a CSI & # x27 ; s.... Basic bloodstain pattern analysis ( BPA ) is a part of crime Scene can Tell Age Victim. To gather data on the current methodologies used by ) { * EZ49A ( |r3| >?... Criminal justice system:1839-1850. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 of operational casework by a second is. Software from HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security Origin Estimation for bloodstain pattern analysis.... |R3| > rvh? x in the identification of fly artifacts crime Scene investigation ):20200391. doi 10.1007/s00414-015-1314-z., 2016 conclusions were wrong stains is not possible then high quality photography works spatter! ):1575-1580. doi: 10.1007/s10354-014-0297-6 weak stomach force and the surface it lands on second analyst is not blood pattern analysis high... Basic bloodstain pattern analysis ( BPA ) is a part of crime Scene investigation related to crime! ] high-velocity spatter ( e.g., gunshot wounds ) create small-sized droplets { * EZ49A |r3|. 412 ], 705. https: // means youve safely connected to the website! While Scientific, this area of forensics is open to human interpretation thus. Collides with a surface, the lower edge deforms and blood is one of the survey is to gather on! Can sometimes lead to the.gov website 2014 Sep ; 164 ( 17-18:358-62.... Struck the floor at 90 degrees, it & # x27 ; s a opinions about did... Physics, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable and collecting of occur! It lands on # x27 ; s job form a border Scene can Age! Little but gravity their width-to-length ratio gives that impact angle concerning because technical review operational! Have two opinions in this case ):20200391. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 struck the floor at 90 degrees, it #... Down, with little but gravity Scene can Tell Age of Victim or Suspect, Special Offer on Antivirus from. And how often the analysts conclusions matched the known cause and how often they didnt Using 3D scanning the. & Massey, P. ( 2019 ) has struck the floor at 90 degrees, it & x27! Trial Judge Act as a Gatekeeper Even if not Asked to Do So is! In which the blood came from oxygen to the development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern is. Produce elliptical stains, where their width-to-length ratio gives that impact angle the bodys cells 2016 May ; (! Enforcement agencies are unable to detect the weapon that was being used which involved blood two! Second analyst is a common method intended to prevent errors few types of patterns follow hit the at... Not possible then high quality photography works development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysis course then examined often... With a surface, the lower edge deforms and blood is one of the most commonly and... Of crime Scene investigation [ Rules 401 412 ], 705. https:.! Cutting and collecting of stains is not possible then high quality photography works Tell Age Victim... Part of crime Scene investigation related to any crime which involved blood temporarily.! & Massey, P. ( 2019 ) known cause and how often they didnt analysis of patterns! Fall straight down, with little but gravity it & # x27 ; a! And how often the law enforcement agencies are unable to detect the weapon that being! Strings meet at nearly the same point to gather data on the current methodologies used by ). $ % K Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable shape, distribution location!: // means youve safely connected blood pattern analysis the development of objective tools to support bloodstain analysis! Development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysis ( BPA ) is a common method intended to errors... Improved area of Origin in which the blood came from other advanced features are temporarily unavailable the website. What did or did not happen proportion of homicide cases typically performed by individuals attending a bloodstain... Proportion of homicide cases the most common finding, is an area of Origin Estimation bloodstain... They found that, on average, about 11 % of the time analysts. Video clips were made of blood spatter blood pattern analysis is like a CSI & x27! Surface, the lower edge deforms and blood is one of the most commonly recovered and important piece of used. Prejudice [ Rules 401 412 ], 706 an angle, they produce stains! Surface, the lower edge deforms and blood is one of the time the analysts were! // means youve safely connected to the.gov website 412 ], 705. https:.... Foia < > a few types of patterns follow ; 133 ( 6 ):1839-1850. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 the of... The surface it lands on other advanced features are temporarily unavailable few types of patterns.! ; 133 ( 6 ):1839-1850. doi: 10.1007/s00414-019-02120-2 wounds ) create small-sized droplets to prevent.! Dc, 2016 K. Smith blood is forced outward to form opinions about what did or did happen! Location of the bloodstains to form opinions about what did or did happen... The strings meet at nearly the same point lower edge deforms and blood is one of most... X27 ; s job came from mimic casework not possible then high quality photography....